STAFF & LEADERSHIP

STAFF

a man in a plaid shirt smiles for the camera

Joe Castronova

Lead Pastor

joe@pursuereality.org

a woman with short hair and a black shirt smiles for the camera

Lindsey Lautsbaugh

Discipleship Pastor

lindsey@pursuereality.org

a man wearing a black shirt smiling at the camera

Worship Pastor

calvin@pursuereality.org

Calvin Hoffman

Mike Mylin

Executive Pastor

mike@pursuereality.org

Joel Pletcher

Lancaster City Campus Pastor

joel@pursuereality.org

a man with a black shirt smiling at the camera

Connor Mayes

Youth Pastor

connor@pursuereality.org

a woman with long blonde hair is wearing a green jacket smiling at the camera

Julia Pletcher

Communications Director

julia@pursuereality.org

a woman in a black shirt smiles for the camera

Daniele Evans

Leadership Development Director

daniele@pursuereality.org

a woman standing against a wall smiling for the camera

Amy Hicks

Associate Worship Leader

amy@pursuereality.org

a woman in a green vest standing outside smiles for the camera

Helen Doolittle

Interim Communications Director

helen@pursuereality.org

Elijah Cregger

AVL-Production Technician

elijah@pursuereality.org

LEADERSHIP TEAM

The Leadership Team provides vision, oversight, governance and general supervision for Reality Church. They seek to follow the Spirit’s lead to oversee Jesus’s work in the people at Reality. Some churches might call this team their “Elder Team”. This team of made up of Godly and mature men and women from our church body. This team works in cooperation and conjunction with the Lead Pastor, Staff, and Overseers of Reality Church.


Mike serves as Director of Finances. With four kids spread out across Middle School, High School and College, it is a great season of life.

Mike Mylin

Kathy and her husband, Brian, have 3 young adult kids. She is an Interior Designer and Principal at Interior Fancies. Kathy is passionate about residential home design. A few of her favorite things are watching things grow and change with each passing season in her flower gardens and vacationing at Kiawah Island, SC with her family.

a woman wearing glasses and a black shirt smiles for the camera

Kathy Shenk

Brett and his wife, Amanda, have two kiddos, Brayden and Sadie. He's a man of many talents as he's the captain of his hockey team, The Skateful Dead, as well as a key member of the worship team serving as a worship leader, keys player, and drummer.

a man with a beard is wearing a white sweater smiling at the camera

Brett Cole

Tim has gifts of leadership, communication, and making people feel seen. He and his wife, Beth, are two of the smiling faces that will greet you when you arrive at Reality Church. They have two adult daughter and love being grandparents. Tim works for UPMC leading the software team that installs and supports the electronic medical record across the organization.

Tim Schoener

Lee serves as part of the Leadership Team. He can be found throughout almost any event going on within the church. He also is one of our appreciate youth ministry volunteers.

a man with a beard is wearing a purple shirt smiling at a camera

Lee Stoltzfous